Self-builds and complex planning issues

HK Architecture is helping client Max build his own home in curtilage of a listed building

It’s nearly there!

A new-build in Barlborough, which HKA helped its owner/developer to gain planning for, is nearing completion.

The two-storey, two-bedroomed property is now up and the internal fit-out is happening at a rapid pace, with our client Max hands-on in the construction and HKA project-managing

The mezzanine, now boarded for plastering

The building is of traditional construction and faced with local stone. It features an open-plan kitchen, dining and living space, with a separate utility room, two bedrooms and bathroom and an upper mezzanine area in the roof space.

Obtaining permission for this development was long and problematic – the site is within the curtilage of a listed building and additionally a number of objections were raised by neighbours.

Its land is believed to have been the site of an orchard for nearby Barlborough Hall, which is Grade I listed, but in recent years it had become an overgrown wasteland.

It lies opposite Max’s home, Grade II* listed South Lodge, the former gate house for the hall.

Max contacted HKA in 2022 in his search for an architectural practice with experience in listed building and heritage architecture

HKA’s pre-application to the council in 2022 suggesting a single storey, simple bungalow, was received positively.

But the council’s opinion altered after a change in planning personnel. HKA worked painstakingly with the planners to find solutions and submitted four scheme revisions for appraisal. 

But in 2024, the full and listed building application was refused on the grounds that the development would have a detrimental effect on the setting of South Lodge, Barlborough Hall, the Registered Park and Garden and Barlborough Conservation Area, and on the living conditions of future residents in the locality.

Strongly believing that a number of modern homes built from the 70s onwards had already significantly altered the area, and that his project would improve waste land in a prominent view, Max decided to fight on. 

With HKA’s support, an appeal was made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 and a planning inspector appointed by the Secretary of State overturned the council’s decision. 

He commented: “I do not consider it can reasonably be claimed that the site forms part of the setting of Barlborough Hall. Although within the historic  boundary of the Park, the site now clearly reads as part of Park Street, which has a varied character and appearance. 

Client Max (left) checks details with HKA MD Alistair

“As I saw on my visit, the once open setting enjoyed by South Lodge has  been steadily eroded by the introduction of residential development, some of which is of questionable architectural quality.”

He added that the proposed house’s situation, its modest proportions, natural facing materials and detailing, would all help to ensure it would not compete with, or detract from, South Lodge.

Max was very grateful to the HKA team. “It painstakingly provided the planning inspector with evidence of all the efforts to meet the planners’ suggestions and requests. MD Alistair Haxton was focused, resilient, calm and efficient throughout his management of a lengthy and stressful process,” he said.

“The house is now well underway, with ongoing support from HKA, and it’s looking great. It is going to be my home – South Lodge is on the market.”


ALISTAIR:

“It’s been a pleasure working with Max – his vision is fast-becoming a reality thanks to his determination and courage, and the hard graft he has put in during construction. He has worked daily alongside his builder, which has kept his costs down.

“The construction process has been relatively simple and has passed all the usual marker points, such as visits from building regulations inspectors.

“The plot’s historic boundary wall, which had partially collapsed, is being rebuilt as part of the project. An area of land which had become an eyesore is being transformed.”